When a customer asks AI where they can buy a brand, the answer may send them to a fake website or to a web address that no longer works, and more often than not it’s presented as a recommendation. In an English-language test that the brand protection firm Podqi published this month, about 9% of AI answers surfaced a site like this. The addresses that AI gives out come from what it has read, so our position is that your website, your official sales channels and the way you’re described elsewhere need to be sorted out now, and they need to agree with each other. If your own official version isn’t clear, AI will use something else as the answer.
What happened
Podqi is a San Francisco-based company that sells brand protection: it finds websites that impersonate brands and files takedown requests. It shared this test exclusively with the US tech site The Verge, which ran the story on 12 November. Podqi has also put up a research page on its own website, and the Taiwanese tech news site TechNews reported on it the following day.
In September, Podqi took 151 brands in fashion, beauty, supplements and other categories and put five English-language questions to ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity, such as “Besides [brand]’s website, where else can I buy it?” It then checked every website that the AI answers mentioned, one by one. According to The Verge’s report, risky sites fall into three kinds: first, sites that appear to impersonate a brand or sell suspected counterfeits; second, old brand web addresses that someone else has re-registered; and third, dead sites where there’s nothing to buy.
About 9% of the answers put a site like this in front of the shopper. The share was higher for some engines than others, but none of the three was at zero. How AI described these sites matters too: in more than half of these answers, the risky site was recommended as a place to shop, and very few warned the shopper to be careful.
A few things need to be clear up front. Podqi sells this kind of service itself, and its research page doesn’t mention any third-party validation. The questions were ones that Podqi wrote itself in English rather than real people’s conversations; it didn’t test Chinese, and there’s no data from Taiwan. The brands were chosen in advance and include heavily counterfeited streetwear labels. What it measured is what appeared in the answers, and no links were clicked, so it says nothing about how many people were actually scammed. It’s also just a snapshot from September. Because of these limits, the 9% figure can’t simply be carried over to Taiwan.
Why it matters to you
Customers in Taiwan can already ask AI in Chinese where to buy things. On 9 November Google launched a Chinese-language shopping feature for Gemini in Taiwan, and its announcement says that it lists prices and where to buy for customers. Whatever language a customer asks in, the web addresses that AI gives come from what it has read, such as your website, your shop on a marketplace, product databases and articles that other people have written about you. If those places say different things, wherever it happens to pick up from is where the customer may end up.
Say, for example, that you make fish noodles in Nangan, in the Matsu Islands. A few years ago you built your own online shop, then moved to an e-commerce platform with a new web address and let the old one lapse when it expired, but the unboxing posts that people wrote back then still link to the old address. One day a customer asks AI: “Where can I buy Example fish noodles from Matsu online, without going all the way to Matsu? Do they have an official website?” The official website that AI gives is the old address. The customer clicks through and there’s nothing to buy, and if someone else has already registered that address, what they see may be a shop that looks like yours but isn’t.
Podqi’s research page has a subheading about exactly this: “Today’s dead domains are tomorrow’s fakes.” Once a web address lapses without being renewed, anyone can re-register it and use it.
What to do about it
Act now. Every time a customer asks where to buy, AI picks out web addresses again, and that keeps happening for as long as customers keep asking. While your old address is still sitting in other people’s articles, it can be picked at any time.
What you need to do is put together the official version: which web addresses are yours and where people can buy from you, written out in text on your website. Everything outside your website, from marketplace shops and stockists to articles that other people have written about you, needs to give the same places to buy as your website does. Podqi’s first recommendation for brands is along the same lines: put a page listing your official sales channels on your website, so that AI has one correct list to copy.
Once the official version is in place, you still need to be able to tell which of the addresses that AI gives out aren’t yours, and it’s easy for business owners to get this wrong when they look for themselves. Podqi tells brands to watch out for addresses like “yourbrand-shop.com”, which look like yours at a glance, and you may well have forgotten what the address that you dropped a few years ago even looked like.
If you’d like to see which addresses AI gives when it’s asked about your shop, you can start by arranging a demo with one of geoweb.tw’s consultants, who will run a round of questions live. The consultant will ask ChatGPT and Gemini the kind of question that Podqi tested, in Chinese and using your shop’s name: where can I buy it, and is there an official website? Then they’ll go through the addresses that come back with you one at a time, so that you can spot which ones aren’t yours and which ones you stopped using long ago. The official version on your website only counts if AI can understand it, so the demo also scores your website across 12 dimensions with geoweb.tw’s free GEO audit.
After the demo, if you want to do this for the long haul, managed GEO uses this official version as its starting point, and we take the whole job off your hands: we write the official version out clearly on your website, we list the places elsewhere that say where to buy from you and compare each one with your site, and we regularly put the “where to buy” questions that customers ask to ChatGPT, Gemini and other leading AI engines, save the answers and check whether the addresses that they give customers are yours.
Further reading
- A fake brand, 56 questions, and Perplexity got 40% of them wrong — Ahrefs invented a brand that doesn’t exist and tested AI engines on it; where the official FAQ was specific, ChatGPT mostly cited it in its answers
- Renamed and moved, but AI still describes the old company — old names and addresses stay on other people’s pages, and AI still picks them up when it searches the web
- Gemini launches Chinese-language shopping in Taiwan — customers in Taiwan can already ask Gemini to recommend products and list where to buy them